× HomeOur Services  About Us  Recent SuccessesTestimonialsNews & Videos  Contactفارسی中文
Contact Our Firm

Sexual & Domestic Assault Wins

Book a Consultation Now

The criminal justice system can be daunting, but you don’t need to go through it alone. Our Criminal lawyers are here to guide you every step of the way.

Contact Our Firm

 

Joseph A. Neuberger, recognized by Best Lawyers 2027 in Criminal DefenceNeuberger & Partners LLP, recognized by Best Lawyers 2027 in Criminal Defence

Sexual & Domestic Assault Wins

Rex v. F.F. (2024)

Client found not guilty of historical sexual assaults involving his daughter, after three-day trial in the Ontario Superior Court, Toronto. F.F. was having major challenges with his daughter doing her chores, attending school, and completing school studies. F.F. came from a very traditional Latin background where discipline was very important. The complainant was spending time online and had fallen into a poor group of friends. She became belligerent and defiant. F.F. caught her online on an adult chat site that he believed she was communicating with older men. F.F. lost his cool and threatened to kick her out of the house. The complainant believed him and called 911. She alleged that when she was 6 and 7 years of age, he sexually assaulted her and had been mean to her ever since. F..F. was charged with Sexual Assault, Sexual Interference, and Invitation to Sexual Touching. Joseph Neuberger was retained to defend F.F. Diana Davison assisted with the defence. Joseph gathered a history of messages between the parents and the complainant as she often refused to come out of her room. Thus, they could only communicate by text. The messages confirmed the home dynamic and F.F.’s complainants about her behavior. At some point, a tech expert assisted with the defence to obtain the chat and online history of the complainant simply showing the sites that she was viewing which indeed had adult content and contact with older men. At trial, Joseph Neuberger cross-examined the complainant extensively on the challenges with her father, the messages, he online history and then broke down the alleged mechanics of the sexual assault allegations. The timing was problematic, and Joseph Neuberger was able to get the complainant to admit that in fact during the time that she said the sexual assaults occurred, the mother was home and assisting with bedtime routines and often F.F. had to assist the complainant’s brother who has autism requiring a lot of attention. The complainant also completely forgot that the family had moved homes and during the time she first alleged the sexual abuse, she in fact had been sharing a bedroom with her brother, contrary to her original statement to police. F.F. testified and was believed by the court. After submissions, the Court found Mr. F.F. not guilty of all charges.

R v S.J. (2024)

The client was charged with Utter Death Threats x 2. The complainant alleged that the defendant made threats to have him killed. The dispute arose over commercial loans. The complainant had taken several large loans from the defendant’s Corporation for the purpose of several construction projects. The complainant also alleged that the defendant had fraudulently placed liens on 5 commercial properties and provided police with materials to support their allegation of fraud. The fraud allegation was transferred to the Police Fraud Unit. The complainant provided the Police with a witness statement to support their allegation that the complainant’s life was in danger. The Crown was seeking a jail sentence. The client retained Joseph Neuberger and Grazia Condello. After reviewing the disclosure and the Commercial litigation materials, Ms. Condello requested further disclosure, including that police interview the witness to confirm the validity of the statement. It was discovered that the complainant changed the witness statement before emailing it to the police and the statement provided to police was false. He said his conversation with the accused was not about the complainant’s life being in danger, but about the complainant having financial difficulties. Mr. Neuberger and Ms. Condello prepared a package for the Crown including Commercial litigation materials showing significant inconsistencies in the complainant’s statement. The complainant’s motive to fabricate was predicated on having the liens on his properties removed as he was unable to pay back the commercial loans. It was also shown the complainant interfered with the administration of justice by changing the witness’s statement. The Crown withdrew the charges on the basis that there was no reasonable prospect of conviction.

Rex v. B.C. (2024)

Charge of Domestic Assault withdrawn prior to trial, Toronto. It was alleged that B.C. became physical with his wife during an argument. The wife called the police and B.C. was arrested. B.C. retained Tyler Alviano of Neuberger & Partners LLP to defend him. Despite significant delay in receiving disclosure Tyler was able to move the matter along and encouraged the Crown to resolve this matter for a peace bond once B.C. attended 16 sessions of private therapy, with a report detailing his progress. The statement of the complainant was vague as to the details leading up to the assault whereas the client was very clear in the argument and that the complainant was threatening to contact police. However, the client was content to take sessions on conflict management and the complainant wanted to reconcile. Rather than a trial, it was best to reconcile the couple. Thus, upon receipt of the report, the charge were withdrawn and the client signed a common law peace bond.

Rex v. S.D. (2024)

Client found not guilty of multiple counts of historical sexual assault and sexual interference charges after a four-day trial, Oshawa. S.D. was in a highly acrimonious divorce from his wife who happens to be a family lawyer. About a year into the divorce proceedings, their daughter stopped all contact with S.D., and S.D. sought a number of methods to have renewed contact with his daughter, including reunification therapy. After arbitration and therapy, the daughter complainant told her Vice Principle that she did not want her father to have any details about her education because he sexually abused her. Eventually, S.D. is charged with numerous counts of sex assault and sexual interference. S.D. retained Joseph Neuberger, Neuberger & Partners LLP, Toronto Criminal Lawyers. After receiving disclosure, it was notable that the former wife of the client was not interviewed as part of the police investigation. Joseph Neuberger and Diana Davison obtained all the family court documents, which included evidence of parental alienation on the part of S.D’s former wife. The defence gathered years of photographs and videos from S.D. as he was a dedicated father and enjoyed taking photos of family trips, and his activities with his daughter, both before and after the separation from his former wife. Joseph Neuberger brought an application to have the photographs admitted at trial for cross-examination of the complainant. The motion was granted. At trial, extensive cross-examination focused on various statements the complainant made about the reasons for ending contact with her father, and then put to the complainant at least 50 photographs spanning the years of the historical allegations. During cross-examination, the complainant continued to double down on her allegations and insert new evidence and allegations. This led to further cross-examination and eventually demonstrated an alignment with the mother post separation. The complainant blamed the father for the sale of the family home, the breakdown of the marriage, and the language used underscored her alignment with her mother not only in the divorce but to remove S.D. from her life which was something the former wife of S.D. sought. S.D. was prepared for testimony at trial. Extensive time was spent with S.D. At trial S.D. testified very well and ultimately was believed by the Court. Extensive written defence submissions were filed. The Court found S.D. factually innocent of the sexual assault and sexual interference charges.

Rex v. C.L. (2024)

Sex Assault Charges Dismissed following four-day Superior Court trial, Toronto. The accused was charged with Sexual Interference, Sexual Assault, and Forcible Confinement. The charges all related to one Complainant who was 8 years old at the time of the allegation. The complainant and her mother were visiting relatives where the accused also resided. While not relatives, the parties were known to each other and had interacted together at other events and family gatherings. The offences were alleged to have occurred in the accused’s bedroom at the residence during a family event which was taking place downstairs at the time. The complainant testified that the accused touched her in a sexual manner including “French Kissing”, prevented her from leaving his bedroom, and touched her genitals. C.L. retained Michael Bury of Neuberger & Partners LLP, Toronto Criminal Lawyers, to represent him. Following a contested trial which included an extensive cross-examination of the complainant, the trial judge found the accused not guilty on the basis that the Crown had not proven its case beyond a reasonable doubt despite both purported physical evidence and evidence of the Crown witnesses including both the complainant and her mother.

Rex v. A.F.S. (2024)

Charges of Sexual Assault x 2, Sexual Assault Choking, Assault Causing Bodily Harm, Assault, Forcible Confinement, Mischief Under and Threaten Death, all withdrawn on the first day of trial, Oshawa. A.F.S. was living at home with his spouse during the initial stages of their separation. A.F.S. rejected overtures to reconcile and moved forward with divorce. His wife went to police and complained of intimate partner abuse including sexual abuse both current and historical in nature. A.F.S. retained Joseph Neuberger of Neuberger & Partners LLP, Toronto Criminal Lawyers, to defend him. Joseph Neuberger reviewed the disclosure and obtained from the client a fairly extensive history of messaging between him and the complainant over the last twelve months of the relationship demonstrating that A.S.F. was distancing himself from contact and communication with the complainant; was nothing but polite and but was firm in his rejection of requests to reconcile and to have intimate time together. It was clear the complainant was pursuing A.S.F., and the complainant was expressing her frustration and rejection. Just after the complainant went to police, the complainant disclosed to the police an email she allegedly sent to A.S.F. dated the day prior to her statement to police, telling A.S.F. that he could not sexually assault her. Joseph Neuberger was convinced this email was constructed to provide some confirmation of her allegation and prior disclosure. Jospeh Neuberger asked for the complainant’s phone to be secured for disclosure of the meta data of the email. The complainant refused and no disclosure was provided of the meta data to establish when the email was created. Further, Joseph Neuberger, brought a 276/278 Application to admit “other sexual” history evidence and all the records – the messages between the complainant and A.S.F. The Application was successful and on the first day of trial, the complainant would not attend court for trial. As such, the charges were withdrawn.

R. v. D.S. (2024)

D.S. was charged with two counts of Assault and one count of Utter Threat out of Newmarket courthouse. D.S. has been married to the complainant for almost 15 years. The two had children together. D.S. and the complainant were going through turbulent times in their marriage and the complainant had cheated on D.S. with D.S.’s friend. This resulted in more arguments between D.S. and the complainant. At some point D.S. wanted to hug the complainant against her will. This was recorded by the complainant. It was also alleged that the accused pushed the complainant on another occasion and told her that he was going to “have her dead”. D.S. retained Mariya Protsenko to defend his criminal charges. Mariya requested the client provide their text message history between D.S. and the complainant. Mariya carefully reviewed disclosure and had the client attend counseling. At the pre-trial, Mariya presented to the assigned Crown Attorney a series of text messages that contradicted the complainant’s utter threat allegations. Even though one of the assault allegations was recorded, Mariya was able to convince the assigned Crown Attorney to withdraw once D.S. entered into a peace bond. Thus, the Crown withdrew the Domestic Assault charge and the Utter Threat charge.

R. v. P.H. (2024)

Charge of Utter Threat withdrawn prior to setting trial date, Milton. P.H. and his neighbour had bad relations. The neighbour alleged that P.H. made racially charged comments full of hatred against him and threatened to hurt him. The utter threat was labelled as hate crime and was taken very seriously by police. In addition, the neighbour presented text messages to the police that could be interpreted to confirm the discriminatory hatred against the neighbor. P.H. retained Mariya Protsenko of Neuberger and Partners, Toronto Criminal Lawyers to defend him. Mariya received disclosure and studied it carefully including the statement of neighbour. Mariya sought from the client a detailed history between him and the complainant including other messages disclosing the true nature of their disputes. Further, the client provided letters from his co-workers, friends, family members and other neighbours that contradicted the complainant’s version of events. Mariya provided defence disclosure including a proper read of the full history of messages demonstrating that the text messages could be read as not discriminatory in nature given the full context. Accordingly, the Crown Attorney withdrew the charge when the client entered into a common law peace bond.

Rex v. Y.L. (2024)

Charges of Assault with a Weapon and Obtain Sexual Services for Consideration, withdrawn, Newmarket. Y.L. had attended an establishment for a massage and at some point, an argument broke out with staff at the spa. The staff called police and Y.L. was charged. Joseph Neuberger was retained to defend the charges. Y.L. insisted that he was attacked by a staff member with a knife. Joseph Neuberger subpoenaed the security camera footage from the spa. It was ultimately provided to the Crown and disclosed to the defence. It did show that Y.L. was threatened with a knife. Joseph Neuberger conducted several pre-trials but sent the client for therapy in regard to the harms of the sex trafficking industry, and about his judgement in that regard. The report was very positive. In addition, Y.L. completed 50 hours of community service. Joseph Neuberger established to the Crown that his client was acting in self-defence but the other charge of obtaining services was clearly made out. That said, a negotiated resolution for a common law peace bond was arranged given the up-front work done by the client. Accordingly, all charges were withdrawn, and the client signed a common law peace bond.

Rex v. W.W. (2024)

Charge of Domestic Assault withdrawn prior to trial, Toronto. It was alleged that W.W. assaulted his girlfriend during an argument. Security guards at the apartment called the police in response to the argument. After the police met with both, W.W. was arrested. S.B. retained Tyler Alviano of Neuberger & Partners LLP, Toronto Criminal Laweyers, to defend him. Tyler extensively reviewed the disclosure and conducted multiple pre-trials with the assigned Crown, noting certain inconsistencies in the evidence. A resolution was negotiated where W.W. undertook a conflict management program and after completion the charge of Assault was withdrawn.

Past results are not necessarily indicative of future results and that the amount recovered and other litigation outcomes will vary according to the facts in individual cases.

CONTACT INFORMATION


PHONE: (416) 364-3111
FAX: (416) 364-3271