The criminal justice system can be daunting, but you don’t need to go through it alone. Our Criminal lawyers are here to guide you every step of the way.
Contact Our Firm

S.M. found Not Guilty following a trial on charges of Sexual Assault and Sexual Interference in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Brampton. S.M.’s step-daughters, the complainants, alleged that during a four year period S.M. sexually assaulted them in the family residence despite the presence of several other family members living regularly at the residence during the entire time. The case rested entirely on the words of two young girls when their biological father brought them to the police and each sat down, one after the other, with the police investigator. There was no forensic evidence, no medical evidence, no admissions and no independent eyewitness. Nothing in the trial confirmed, from a source independent of the children and the adults who questioned them, that S.M. sexually assaulted them. Prior to going to the police, the biological father regularly questioned the girls and suggested that S.M. had done something to them. S.M., as a result, was charged with multiple sexual offences. Reliability was the central issue at trial. Following cross-examination of the witnesses by Michael Bury, it was apparent that the evidence had been tainted as a result of the biological father’s questioning, regular conversations between the complainants and leading questions by the police investigator. Applying the relevant legal principles, the trial judge found S.M. Not Guilty after the Crown failed to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.

After a four-day trial in the Ontario Court of Justice, Kitchener, client found not guilty of Sex Assault, Sexual Interference and Invitation to Sexual Touching. C.J. attended a university party where the invitation was over WeChat to a university group chat. During the party, C.J. met two young ladies, one who attended his university. He was introduced to the complainant, and they spent several hours talking and playing drinking games. At some point the two went to a bedroom and became intimate. The complainant fell asleep after intimacy. C.J. left the bedroom and played a few more games. He felt tired and then left the party but connected with the friend of the complainant before leaving to ensure that if he left, he would not disappoint the complainant. The next day, he got a call from the complainant and her friend who was a university student informing that the complainant alleged she was 15 and he raped her. Immediately he was told that she wanted “compensation”. He met her later in the day and a settlement agreement was written by the complainant, but C.J. refused to sign it and accused her of extorting him. The complainant went immediately after the refusal to pay to police and C.J. was charged. Joseph Neuberger of Neuberger & Partners LLP was retained with Diana Davison assisting. Joseph Neuberger obtained C.J.’s WeChat history with the complainant’s friend, pictures and other communications including a picture of the settlement agreement. The defence provided disclosure to the Crown. A further statement was taken by the police from the complainant, but the Crown pursued the prosecution even thought the complainant admitted in the statement that it was her idea to seek “compensation”. At trial, extensive cross-examination focused on the circumstances around the complainant who was 15, attending a university party that was labelled by her close friend as a “university drinking party” and her role in pursuing C.J. Messages were put to the complainant and her friend in cross-examination. During high pressure cross-examination over the messages leading to demands for money, the complainant relented and agreed that her and her friend conspired to obtain a financial gain to manipulate a police investigation. This resulted in an admission of a criminal conspiracy. The complainant’s friend testified and it was obvious that she has spoken to the complainant after she was cross-examined by Joseph Neuberger. In order to avoid criminal responsibility for extortion, the friend started to blame the complainant for being the initiator of intimate contact with C.J. and it became obvious that the two had colluded and the evidence was not only unreliable but fabricated. Accordingly, the Crown agreed to a directed verdict of not guilty on all three counts.

Client found not guilty of five counts of sexual assault after a four-day trial in the Ontario Court of Justice, Newmarket. P.L. had been a massage therapist for over 15 years at the time he was charged for allegations of three clients. Joseph Neuberger of Neuberger & Partners LLP was retained. The crown brought a similar act application to support cross-count evidence to bolster the credibility of the complainants. This was challenged at trial. Each complainant had described somewhat similar issues regarding the massages but many of the factors were not unique, and many were simply the factor of the place and circumstances in which each allegation arose. For example, each complainant was female. Each were getting massages to sensitive areas and by a male therapist. At trial, careful attention was paid in cross-examination of the message technique, consent forms signed to the extent of the injuries being treated, and the therapeutic approach to each of the patient/complainant. The Crown did not call an expert in their case however, in cross-examination Joseph Neuberger challenged the complainants on the areas that needed to be treated how to properly address each of their injuries and each complainant seemed to suggest that they knew better as to how to treat their injuries. Two complainants had been long standing client’s and the third was a first-time client, but all had specific injuries that required treatment. Part of the defence was that P.L. because he was in his mid-50s at the time of the alleged sexual assaults, was experiencing arthritis in his hands, and back. He too had injuries from his previous career and at times may have been sloppy in draping techniques and touches, but he did not do anything for a sexual purpose. Each complainant described touching in sensitive areas but not any type of penetration. The areas described that were alleged to have been touched on purpose were all possibly touched incidental to his legitimate massages techniques that were proper legitimate techniques to address their issues. One complainant who had been a client for over 5 years kept returning and only stopped because he was no longer working at the clinic. That complainant was aggressively challenged on her allegations and frankly tried to mislead the court about how her injury had been treated in the past and during the impugned sessions. P.L. testified and gave consistent, logical, and enthusiastic evidence about how he treated the three complainants. He was not shaken in cross by the Crown and was believed by the judge. The similar act application was denied, and P.L. was found not guilty of five charges of sexual assault.

Eight Counts of Assault, Forcible Confinement, Mischief, Utter Threats withdrawn by the Crown in the Ontario Court of Justice, Brampton. H.M., a general contractor, was charged with multiple counts involving intimate partner violence allegations made by his former girlfriend after their relationship ended. The girlfriend had several mental health issues acknowledged by her own family and prone to violence against H.M. during their relationship. Initially, the Crown was intent on proceeding and three days were set aside for a contested trial. Michael Bury spent considerable time negotiating with the Crown and highlighting the obvious problems with the Crown’s case given the girlfriend’s mental health issues and lack of cooperation with the prosecution. The Crown, accordingly, agreed to withdraw the charges against H.M.

Two charges of Sexual Assault withdrawn by the Crown in the Ontario Court of Justice, Toronto. B.C., a registered massage therapist, was charged with two counts of sexual assault following allegations made by a former patient. The patient had seen B.C. on eight separate occasions and claimed that on two occasions he had inserted his fingers into her vagina without consent on the pretence of giving her a muscular internal massage. Despite the allegations, the patient continued to see B.C. for massages. Initially, the Crown was intent on proceeding and three days were set aside for a contested trial. Michael Bury spent considerable time negotiating with the Crown and highlighting the obvious problems with the Crown’s case given the patient’s uncertainty about what had transpired, especially since she admitted to being a heavy marijuana user and smelled of marijuana during the treatment sessions. The Crown, accordingly, agreed to withdraw the charges against B.C.

Client charged with one count of sexual assault and one count of assault, with a five-day trial scheduled at the Ontario Court of Justice, Toronto. The complainant alleged non-consensual sexual touching by her friend during an impromptu massage followed later by several attempts at unwanted kissing. RR vehemently denied all allegations. Mr. Whitfield prepared a forensic cross-examination focused on material inconsistencies in the Complainant’s statement. During discussions with the Crown, Mr. Whitfield disclosed a memo based on the cross-examination to establish no reasonable prospect of conviction and as a result the crown withdrew the charges ahead of trial. The parties agreed to a peace bond resolution that admitted no criminal or civil liability, and which did not admit the facts. Mr. Whitfield worked collaboratively with the Crown to craft conditions agreeable to RR and the Complainant.

Client found not guilty of two counts of sexual assault spanning a 22-year relationship and marriage with over 742 alleged sex assaults, after a four-day trial in the Superior Court, Toronto. J.Z. and the complainant commenced dating in 1997 and eventually got married. They separated in 2019. The couple had three kids and had what seemed a normal marriage. The relationship began to deteriorate in the mid-2000s after J.Z. sustained multiple concussions leading to him being under employed that created significant financial pressure. J.Z. is a teacher but ran a sports training business on weekends and due to his injuries, he was not able to perform as well in his business. The complainant started to allege that J.Z. had sexually assaulted her as far back as when they started dating by forcing himself on her when he was sleeping. Later, the complaints grew to include alleged sexual assaults that occurred likely when he was awake but pretending to be asleep during which he choked her and then ridiculed her after. The arguments grew and J.Z. told the complainant that he wanted a divorce and to sell the house after a major blow up regarding these allegations. J.Z. denied the allegations and said it made no sense. J.Z. and the complainant eventually filed for divorce which became highly contentious. There were issues of parental alienation and J.Z. would not agree to the settlement the complainant offered. The complainant went to the police and J.Z. was charged with two global counts of sex assault that alleged over the entire relationship and marriage she was continuously sexually assaulted resulting in over 742 acts of sex assault. J.Z. was removed from the house and then was cut off from contact with the children. Joseph Neuberger of Neuberger & Partners LLP was retained to defend the case. Diana Davison joined the defence team. The defence was able to obtain several documents written by the complainant during the divorce and police investigation that the Crown alleged were third party records. Joseph Neuberger used these written “stories” for cross-examination. In addition, the family court filings were a fertile area of material to cross-examine on. A motion had to be brought to ask certain questions related to “other sexual activity” that was successful. After an extensive and detailed cross-examination of the complainant, J.Z. testified and did well. The judge found J.Z. credible and found serious credibility issues with the complainant. For example, Joseph Neuberger submitted to the court in closing argument that the complainant alleged that the majority of sexual assaults were all the same with only memory of one being slightly different. Further, the first sex assault was to have occurred when the two first started dating and was a very brutal violent sexual assault. At the time, the two were not living together and the complainant lived at home with a loving family and a good circle of friends. It was argued that the complainant would not have continued to date J.Z. had this violent sexual assault occurred. Although the court noted this argument was close to myth-based reasoning about how a real victim should behave, Joseph Neuberger submitted that in the totality of evidence, it was well beyond common sense that the complainant would have continued to date J.Z. and be subjected to endless sexual assaults even before they were engaged. The lack of any real specificity of the sexual assaults other than being all the same, rendered her credibility highly suspect and in the defence position a fabrication. Ultimately, J.Z. was found not guilty on both counts.

J.W. was charged with six counts of Assault, two counts of Assault with a Weapon, Utter Threat and Mischief Under $5,000 out of the Toronto courthouse. J.W. and his wife were planning to purchase a house. J.W.’s family transferred J.W. and his wife a large sum of money for the purchase of the house. Money was deposited into the shared bank account. However, the relationship between J.W. and his wife started to deteriorate. On the day of the arrest, J.W. noticed that money for the house purchase was transferred from their shared account into the wife’s personal account. J.W. confronted his wife about it. The two started to argue and the argument became heated. J.W. allegedly threatened his wife to kill her if she doesn’t return money. It was also alleged that he would choke her. The wife called 911 and provided a statement to the police. She recalled alleged historic assaults that involved pushing, hitting, using objects to threaten her and destroying her property by J.W. J.W. retained Mariya of Neuberger & Partners Criminal Lawyers Toronto. Mariya gathered all the financial documents from J.W. She also reviewed the disclosure in detail. During a pre-trial with the assigned Crown Attorney, she convinced the Crown Attorney that there was no reasonable prospect of conviction. All the charges against J.W. were withdrawn.

Charges of Domestic Assault, and Utter Death Threats x 3 withdrawn after extensive pre-trials, Toronto. B.C. and the complainant were in a relationship while attending university. The two had at times an unhealthy dynamic and after months of arguments and copious amounts of messages exchanged, the complainant attended campus police and then gave a statement to police resulting in his arrest. Joseph Neuberger and Grace Condello were retained to defend the charges. The complainant in her statement laid out a narrative of B.C. being aggressive, threatening and essentially dominating in the relationship. We were able to extract from B.C.’s phone a massive volume of messages between he and the complainant. The dynamic was completely different. Joseph Neuberger prepared a chart and memo to the Crown laying out the chronology of messages and how they undermined the complainant’s narrative. After multiple pre-trials, the charges of Assault and Utter Threats were withdrawn.

P.A. was charged with Assault, Forcible Confinement, and Utter Threats. P.A. was involved in a verbal argument with her boyfriend that escalated to a physical confrontation. Despite P.A. locking herself in her room, the complainant called police. P.A. retained Grace Condello who arranged a pre-trial with the assigned Crown early in the process. At the pre-trial it was discussed that the boyfriend initiated the argument by name-calling P.A. Ms. Condello and the Crown agreed that it was not in the public interest to prosecute. The charges were withdrawn prior to the first court date.
Past results are not necessarily indicative of future results and that the amount recovered and other litigation outcomes will vary according to the facts in individual cases.