× HomeOur Services  About Us  Recent SuccessesTestimonialsNews & Videos  Contactفارسی中文
Contact Our Firm

Sexual & Domestic Assault Wins

Book a Consultation Now

The criminal justice system can be daunting, but you don’t need to go through it alone. Our Criminal lawyers are here to guide you every step of the way.

Contact Our Firm

 

Joseph A. Neuberger, recognized by Best Lawyers 2027 in Criminal DefenceNeuberger & Partners LLP, recognized by Best Lawyers 2027 in Criminal Defence

Sexual & Domestic Assault Wins

R. v. L.G. (2019)

Charge of Domestic Assault withdrawn after several pre-trials with the prosecutor in the Ontario Court of Justice, Scarborough. The complainant, L.G.’s wife, was upset with L.G. for smoking inside the house. They had an argument and L.G allegedly pushed the complainant to the floor. The complainant tried to get up, however, L.G. kept pushing her so that she would stay down. The complainant also indicated to the prosecutor assigned to this matter that she was tortured and tormented by L.G. throughout many years and that she wanted to proceed to a trial. Mariya Protsenko of Neuberger & Partners was retained by the client on this matter. Mariya conducted a number of pre-trials with the persecutor including face to face meetings and conversations at the courthouse. The prosecutor agreed to withdraw the charge against L.G upon him entering into a common law peace bond. No volunteer work or counseling was required. L.G. attended Scarborough courthouse with Mariya and upon entering into a common law peace bond, his charge was

 

Regina v. C.J. and A.J.C. (2019)

Charges of Assault and Criminal Harassment withdrawn prior to setting trial date in the Ontario Court of Justice, Newmarket.  C.J. and A.J.C. were driving together and there was a road incident with another car that then followed them to a mall parking lot.  Once out of the cars an argument ensued and a physical altercation.  Part of the altercation was captured by video surveillance from local stores.   Joseph Neuberger and John Navarrete were retained as the defence lawyers.  After a careful review of the surveillance, there were some frames that were enhanced by the defence which appeared to show the complainant making gestures prior to the physical altercation that could be viewed as assaultive and there could be an argument for self-defence on top of the fact that the complainant had followed C.J, and A.J.C. to the parking lot.  After two judicial pre-trials, an agreement was reached for all parties to take some anger management counseling related to road rage and at the end of the therapy it was agreed all charges would be withdrawn.  Once the therapy was completed the charges were formally withdrawn.

 

Regina v. M.Y. (2019)

Charges of Domestic Assault and Mischief Under withdrawn after extensive pre-trial discussions with the Crown.  The complainant and M.Y. were in the midst of a separation.  An argument erupted over an issue about support.  The complainant called police and alleged that M.Y. had pushed her and grabbed her.  M.Y. was arrested, and ordered to have no contact and not return to the home.  Joseph Neuberger was retained as the defence lawyer.  During the course of the criminal proceeding, the complainant wrote to the Crown that she wished to reconcile and have marriage counselling.  This was communicated to Joseph Neuberger.  Joseph Neuberger spoke with his client and he was in favour of marriage counselling and reconciliation.  Joseph Neuberger had several pre-trials with the Crown Attorney and worked out a therapy program for M.Y. that would then turn into marriage counselling. The Crown agreed to withdraw the charge after M.Y. completed 12 sessions successfully.  This was done, and the charges were withdrawn.

Regina v. J.C. (2019)

Charges of Domestic Assault and Mischief withdrawn after extensive discussions with the Crown.  J.C. was charged by his soon to be former wife with domestic violence allegations arising from an argument over separation. Joseph Neuberger was retained as his criminal defence lawyer.  Once disclosure was received and thoroughly reviewed, it became apparent that the purported assault would have resulted in severe injuries yet, there were no injuries. Defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger met on three occasions with the assigned Crown and negotiated a withdrawal if the client completed a program of anger management and conflict management therapy.  After successful completion, both charges were withdrawn.

Regina v. G.L. (2019)

Charges of Assault and Mischief withdrawn prior to trial.  G.L. was alleged to have been highly intoxicated at a bar and was involved in a fight that resulted in some injury to the complainant and damage to the bar.  Defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger was retained.  Joseph Neuberger sought the video surveillance from inside the bar, and even though the surveillance video was not the best quality, it appeared that G.L. was attacked first due to some verbal argument.  Joseph Neuberger had the client attend for alcohol abuse therapy and tendered the report and the surveillance video to the Crown.  After a fruitful pre-trial, the Crown agreed to withdraw the charges.

Regina v. H.B. (2019)

Client found not guilty after two day trial in Newmarket, Ontario Court of Justice, of charges of Luring x 4, and Communicating to obtain the sexual services of a minor x 2, all arising from the police project Raphael.   H.B. was 52 years of age at the time and had looked at the backpages for an escort.  He eventually made arrangements to meet two service providers at a hotel and was arrested as it was alleged that he was communicating with an undercover officer pretending to be a 14 year old escort.  Joseph Neuberger was retained as the criminal defence lawyer.  When Joseph Neuberger took over the file, an extensive meeting with the client yielded information about issues with the client’s phone and he having contacted other service providers.  The police provided in disclosure only the texts messages between the undercover and Mr. H.R. The cell phone extraction report from the police similarly only had messages between H.R. and the undercover officer.  Joseph Neuberger sought an Order releasing the seized phone to the defence to have it forensically reviewed by the defence expert.  The defence expert provided an extraction report that included all other calls and messages between H.R. and other service providers and demonstrated that some messages were truncated and not clear.  The defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger provided the Crown with the defence expert material and also prepared a Compilation Report that included all communications over a two hour period to provide full context to the communications with the undercover officer.  The evidence established that H.R. was confused between two numbers both having area codes of 289 one of which was the undercover officer.  There were numerous messages and it was not a simple back and forth between the officer and H.R. but rather extended well over one hour and 34 minutes.  Further, defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger spent over 70 hours with H.R. preparing him to testify.  At trial, the defence extraction report, and the Compilation Report provided strong evidence to support H.R.’s evidence. The court found that H.R.’s evidence, although having its credibility issues, was not unbelievable and thus raised a reasonable doubt that he knew the alleged age of the pretend escort. Accordingly, the client was found not guilty of all six charges.

R. v. M.T. (2019)

M.T. was originally charged with attempt murder in relation to astabbing incident at a local sports bar and detained in custody. M.T.’s family immediately retained Mr. John Navarrete. Mr. Navarrete spoke to the Crown about the defence position of self-defence regarding the incident in order to obtain bail. Shortly after Crown received the video surveillance of the sports bar which confirmed the triable issue of self defence and thereby consented to client’s release and reduced the charge from attempt murder to aggravated assault, utter threat and carry concealed weapon. Mr. Navarrete later conducted a narrow and focused preliminary hearing cross
examining the alleged victim of the stabbing. Ultimately, the matter went to trial by judge and jury in the  Superior Court of Justice located at 361 University Ave. After a two-week trial where the Crown called over 7 witnesses and Mr. Navarrete called M.T. to describe his self-defensive actions, the client was acquitted of aggravated assault and carry a concealed weapon by the jury and only convicted for uttering a threat. The
client received a conditional discharge as his sentence for that charge.

R. v. R.C. (2019)

R.C. was charged with assault (X4), forcible confinement, sexual assault and breach of probation against his “on and off” again girlfriend. It was alleged that R.C. bound up his girlfriend and held her against her will for over 5 hours, sexually assaulted her and physically hit her. R.C. initially retained Christopher Assie to represent him on this charge and various other related charges involving the same complainant. Mr. Assie conducted a thorough and clinical preliminary inquiry involving cross examining the complainant on various text messages and Facebook postings. R.C.’s matter then was elevated to the Superior Court of Justice at 361 University Ave
where a one-week trial took place before a judge alone with Mr. John Navarrete as his counsel. Mr. Assie and Mr. Navarrete worked collaboratively to ensure that key points of the preliminary inquiry were raised at trial for the benefit of the client. Mr. Navarrete cross examined the complainant on the various postings and text messages and various other issues and met with the client in custody at the Toronto South Detention Centre on several occasions to ensure that he was properly prepared to testify at his own trial. The jury found R.C. not guilty on all charges.

Regina v. N.O. (2019)

Client found not guilty of sexual assault after two day trial in the Ontario Court of Justice.  N.O. had met the complainant on Ashley Madison and started an intimate relationship.  On one night the complainant alleged an act occurred during their sexual encounter where she withdrew consent but all other contact was consensual.  N.O. hired Joseph Neuberger as his defence lawyer.  Joseph Neuberger obtained from the client over 300 messages before and after the alleged sexual assault that provided an extremely rich foundation for cross-examination of the complainant including her intention to meet up with N.O. that night to get drunk and high and forget the evening which went directly to her reliability as a witness. Other messages showed animus after the alleged event due to her financial situation and a friend who also attended the evening and trashed her car.  At trial Joseph Neuberger extensively cross-examined the complainant and established key inconsistencies and issues related to her reliability. Joseph Neuberger and his team spent considerable time preparing N.O. for his testimony.  At the end of the trial N.O.’a evidence was sufficient to raise more than a reasonable doubt on the main issue and as such N.O. was acquitted of the charge.

Regina v. F.L. (2019)

Charge of assault withdrawn in the Ontario Court of Justice Newmarket, after extensive discussions with the Crown.  F.L. was involved in an altercation during his son’s soccer game where a major physical dispute broke out.  Joseph Neuberger was retained as the defence lawyer.  After obtaining disclosure, it was astonishing that the only statements taken were from the team of the complainant and the family of the complainant’s.  Defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger conducted a defence investigation gathering other statements and eventually disclosed the statements to the Crown.  The Crown determined that there was not reasonable prospect of conviction.  As such the charge was withdrawn.

Past results are not necessarily indicative of future results and that the amount recovered and other litigation outcomes will vary according to the facts in individual cases.

CONTACT INFORMATION


PHONE: (416) 364-3111
FAX: (416) 364-3271