The criminal justice system can be daunting, but you don’t need to go through it alone. Our Criminal lawyers are here to guide you every step of the way.
Contact Our Firm
Domestic related charges of Sexual Assault x 2, Assault x 4, Assault with a Weapon, Threaten Death and Cruelty to an Animal, all withdrawn just prior to the commencement of trial. S.J. was in the midst of a separation and a custody battle regarding the complainant and their son. After the commencement of divorce proceedings the complainant went to police and made a number of historical claims of abuse. S.J. was charged. There were three statements from the complainant and some evidence from her father to support her allegations. Joseph Neuberger was eventually retained by the client after his first counsel recommended a guilty plea. Joseph Neuberger and his partner Grace Condello took over the file and interviewed the client extensively. Family court documents were obtained, as well as emails and messages exchanged between the complainant and S.J. leading up to the charges. There were serious financial issues at stake including a $100,000 loan made by S.J. to the father of the complainant. After extensive file investigation, Joseph Neuberger arranged a meeting with the Crown and disclosed various source documents that would have seriously undermined the credibility of the complainant. The Crown agreed in light of the defence material, there was no reasonable prospect of conviction. All charges were thus withdrawn.
Charges of Sexual Assault x 3, Assault, Assault with a Weapon and Utter Threats withdrawn after extensive cross-examination of the complainant at trial. D.M. was in a short two month relationship with the complainant. D.M. had suspicions that the complainant had gone to Niagara Falls with another person and that she was having multiple relationships. My client attended her home and found out that in fact he was correct. An argument ensued and D.M. made a threat about intimate pictures. D.M. left but the complainant called police a week later. While in the police station the complainant alleged that throughout the relationship, he beat her and forced sex on her. The Crown was seeking five to six years. Joseph Neuberger was retained as the defence lawyer. A great deal of time was spent with the client obtaining WeChat messages up to and including the date of the offence and after. It established the complainant had sought compensation or she was go to the police. The compensation was for some damage he caused during their argument and his threat about the pictures. D.M. would not pay $5,000.00 and the complainant indeed went to the police. Joseph Neuberger and Grace Condello, paralegal in the firm, worked on a breakdown of the complainant’s statement in step with all of the messages obtained. At trial, the complainant expanded her allegations to over 20 sexual assaults. Joseph Neuberger surgically cross-examined the complainant about each allegation and established the falsehoods in each and then put to the complainant a series of pictures and messages throughout the relationship that established a loving and respectful relationship save and except for the fact that the complainant carried on a secret relationship. After several hours of cross-examination, the Crown agreed to withdraw at trial.
Charge of Assault withdrawn after extensive pre-trials. F.H. who was in the midst of an ongoing high conflict relationship with her former husband had sole custody of their daughter but during a weekend with the father, there was an alleged complaint of abuse. F.H. was charged with assault. F.H. retained Joseph Neuberger as her defence lawyer. Joseph Neuberger had all statements transcribed. The transcripts were reviewed in conjunction with the video statement of the child complainant and it became fairly clear that during the interview with police and the CAS worker, the child was confused and was using “mom” to refer to another family member as she felt close to that family member like a mother. Joseph Neuberger provided the Crown with the statement and a chart breaking down the statement to expose the errors. In addition, the defence obtain statements from the child’s family physician and teachers about not ever seeing any hint of physical or emotional abuse but to the contrary when seeing the child and F.H. together, there was an observed close bonded relationship. After extensive discussions with the Crown and review of the evidence, Joseph Neuberger was able to establish that there was no reasonable prospect of conviction and the charge was withdrawn.
Charge of Sexual Assault withdrawn prior to the commencement of trial. Q.L, a prominent Real Estate Broker, had become involved with a lady who he business dealings with. One night the two were intimate. The next afternoon, after they had lunch, the complainant attended a police station and made a complaint of sexual assault. Q.L. was charged. Joseph Neuberger was retained as the criminal lawyer to defend the allegations. Joseph Neuberger obtained the statement of the complainant, transcribed it, and then broke it down in time frames to analyze the actions of the complainant. In addition, the smart phone of the client was sent to the defence expert to retrieve messaging between the complainant and Q.L. prior and then after the alleged assault. Sometime later, after a three day trial was set, the complainant started calling Q.L. Defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger had an investigator meet with Q.L. and set up recording devices to monitor and record the calls. The complainant kept calling and all discussions were recorded. The discussions were in Mandarin and Criminal Lawyer Joseph Neuberger sent the recordings to a certified translation service for certified transcription and translation. During the course of additional judicial pre-trials, an arrangement was made to disclose the defence evidence, on a without prejudice basis for an assessment of the prospects of conviction. After extensive discussions, the Crown determined that there was absolutely no prospect of conviction and in fact Q.L. was innocent. Accordingly, the charge was withdrawn.
Client found not guilty after four day trial in the Ontario Court of Justice on charges of Sexual Assault x 2, Kidnapping, Forcible Confinement and Utter Threat. Client got married at 19 to a young lady also 19 who was a Visa student. The marriage was primarily for helping the young lady get status in Canada, but the two came to have affection for each other. However, early on into the relationship Z.C. was discovered to be cheating and this caused a series of high conflict arguments and must turmoil over a six month period of the marriage. At the end of six months, the two separated. In October of 2016, the complainant attended Z.C.’s home and smashed his car. While Z.C. was following her back to her residence (the two had separated), police were called and the complainant alleged the Z.C. had committed two very serious sexual assaults, and a host of other serious offences. Joseph Neuberger was retained as the criminal defence lawyer. There was a team placed on the file with Daisy Zhang, a senior law clerk and a senior paralegal Grace. A large volume of evidence was obtained including two statements; messages and letters as well as statements from alleged witnesses. The case eventually went to trial. Joseph Neuberger and the defence team obtained undisclosed messages sent by the complainant to Z.C. and monitored various social media forums in which the complainant was posting material that showed considerable animus about the cheating but nothing about the alleged violence. At trial, Joseph Neuberger extensively crossed examined the complainant on inconsistencies in her statements in addition put hundreds of messages to the complainant contradicting the sequence of events and the implausibility of events. In addition, during the trial, the complainant continued to post on social media, and on the second day or cross-examination of the complainant, Joseph Neuberger put to the complainant several posts that were highly aggressive in relation to Z.C. and showed a possible fabrication of a letter that she said the complainant wrote. The complainant initially lied about the social media posts, but under continued cross-examination with more posts being shown to the complainant, she relented and admitted the posts. The complainant alleged however that Z.C. had hacked into her account to manipulate the posts and other messages, but the defence expert was able to show that this allegation was false. By the end of the trial, the Court determined that there was insufficient evidence to convict Z.C. of the Sexual and other charges. The client was found not guilty.
Charges of Assault Causing Bodily Harm, Assault with a Weapon, and Assault withdrawn after extensive negotiations with the Crown. The complainant boyfriend of S.W. was attacked by S.W. with a knife and sustained serious head injuries. Joseph Neuberger was retained as the defence lawyer. After review of the statements and interviews with the client, the situation arose from a very heated argument. It became apparent that S.W. became fearful of being attacked by the complainant and proactively obtained a knife to remove the complainant from the apartment. In addition, both parties had consumed a large quantity of alcohol. Joseph Neuberger had the complainant assessment by a therapist and a forensic psychiatrist. The reports suggested a situational psychosis of being attacked by the complainant. After months of therapy and further risk assessment, all defence reports were turned over to the Crown. The Crown agreed with Joseph Neuberger that there was a viable defence and that S.W. had done extensive therapy to address alcohol misuse and to demonstrate no risk. As such, all charges were withdrawn and the client signed a peace bond that would be in effect for 6 months.
Charges of Assault with a Weapon x 2 and Utter Threats x 2 withdrawn after extensive discussions with the Crown. M.A.’ daughter apparently was not following her mother’s rules for the house and after an argument, while at school, the complainant made allegations against M.A. M.A. self-represented herself and wound up setting a trial. After CAS warned M.A. about her losing access to her daughter, M.A. retained Joseph Neuberger to defend the charges. Mr Neuberger reviewed the evidence, conducted a pre-trial and spoke with CAS. He then amended the bail to allow M.A. and her daugheter to enter into joint therapy. After four months of therapy and a very positive report, the Crown agreed that a “child” focused approach is far better than a trial. As such Crown agreed to withdraw all charges.
Charges of Domestic Assault with a Weapon x 2 and Utter Threat x 2 withdrawn after extensive pre-trials with the Crown Attorney Newmarket. M.M. was dating a lady about 25 years younger for about six months. The two had a child together and during the course of living together allegations of domestic violence were made by the complainant. Joseph Neuberger was retained as defence counsel. Joseph Neuberger reviewed the disclosure, had all statements transcribed and then attended the home to view the scene. The description of the alleged assault with a weapon was not plausible given the layout of the room the complainant alleged the two assaults took place. Mr. Neuberger photographed the room and hallway. Then an interview was conducted of the client’s mother how was home during the incident. Joseph Neuberger turned over the defence evidence to the Crown and conducted a number of pre-trials. In the interim, Mr. Neuberger had the client complete an anger management program privately and furnished the Crown with a copy of the report. After further discussions with the Crown, an agreement was reached to withdraw all charges in favour of the client signing a peace bond.
Charges of Assault with a Weapon and Use Imitation Firearm withdrawn prior to trial. The client was charged with having been involved in a road-rage incident. After stopping his vehicle, he allegedly got out, punched the complainant in the head and pulled out a gun. The client retained Christopher Assie as his defence counsel at Neuberger & Partners. After reviewing the disclosure thoroughly, counsel had a number of discussions with the Crown and pointed all of the weaknesses in the case – the most important being that the Crown could not positively prove that the accused was the assailant. The Crown withdrew the charges in exchange for a peace bond. The client was a foreign student and any conviction for the offences would have led to his immediate deportation.
Charges of Assault and Mischief withdrawn after first day of trial. The client was a tow-truck operator. He was alleged to have had an argument with another fellow tow-truck driver. One night, he came across the complainant who was waiting for calls. The accused was alleged to have attacked the complainant and then proceeded to damage the two-truck. The client retained Christopher Assie. After cross-examining the complainant for a day, the prosecutor offered to withdraw the charges if the accused entered into a peace bond promising to stay away from the complainant. The second prosecution witness had not even testified. The client elected to enter into the peace bond and the charge was withdrawn.
Past results are not necessarily indicative of future results and that the amount recovered and other litigation outcomes will vary according to the facts in individual cases.