The criminal justice system can be daunting, but you don’t need to go through it alone. Our Criminal lawyers are here to guide you every step of the way.
Contact Our Firm
Charge of Assault with Weapon withdrawn prior to setting a trial date, Newmarket Court. X.L. and the complainant had a relationship for a short period of time. When X.L. broke up with the complainant, the complainant posted some pictures of X.L. and her son in Wechat, and in an emotional moment and made bad comments about their relationship history. X.L. went to his place asking him to delete the posts, but he refused. X.L. took his phone from the table and deleted the post. The complainant called the police alleging X.L. hit him in his chest with the phone. X.L. was charged with assault with weapon. X.L. retained Daisy Zhang of Neuberger & Partners, Toronto Criminal Lawyers, to defend the charge. After obtaining and reviewing the statements of the complaint and the police officers’ notes, Daisy found one of officer noted X.L had a bad shoulders and could not be handcuffed. Daisy contacted X.L. and confirmed that X.L had a serious frozen shoulder so that it is even difficult for her to lift the arm for dressing. Then Daisy obtained the medical report from X.L.’s family doctor and provided it to the Crown. Through extensive discussion with the Crown, The Crown agreed there is a reasonable doubt that she hit the complaint by phone with bad shoulder. The charge was withdrawn.
Client found not guilty of Assault, Assault Choking, human trafficking x 2, Material Benefit x 2, Procuring, and Advertise Sexual Services, after six-day trial in the Ontario Court of Justice, Newmarket. U.M. was asked by his marijuana supplier to assist with a young lady who came in from a northern part of Ontario. U.M. put her up at two hotels, under his name, address, and points reward number and then later in the week was alleged to have trafficked her for sex. U.M. retained Joseph Neuberger, Neuberger & Partners LLP, Toronto Criminal Defence Lawyers, to represent him on the charges. Joseph Neuberger and Diana Davison, an advocate for falsely accused men, worked on the file. The case was carefully analyzed, and considerable time was placed on drafting cross-examination of the complainant and a witness who was originally charged with the same offences but let off of the charges to give evidence against U.M. At trial, cross-examination was detailed, and persistent which resulted in raising very significant issues of credibility and reliability. The client was prepared to testify and did so at trial. The trial judge quoted extensively from cross-examination of both Crown witnesses and the defence written closing submissions. Key elements were the surveillance footage of the client who did nothing to conceal his identify when booking the young lady into two hotels, no financial documentation to support any funds from sex trafficking, poor recall due to drug use, no actual evidence of any appointments to meet clients, and complete freedom of the complainant to contact her family, and roam around Toronto. There was so much evidence contradicting the complainant that was outlined in the closing written submissions. Further, the other Crown witnesses had significant deficits in her evidence including her interest in the outcome of the trial to ensure her obligation to cooperate with police to give evidence against U.M. so that she was not charged with the same offences. At the conclusion of the matter, the Court determined that U.M. was not guilty of all offences.
client found not guilty of Sexual Assault, Assault Causing Bodily Harm, Assault x 2, and Utter Threats, after a five-day trial in the Ontario Court of Justice, Brampton. A.M. was in a relationship with the complainant for three years. It was not the best relationship as the two often accused each other of infidelity. In December 2018, the complainant had been monitoring A.M.’s Facebook account and caught that he had been with another woman. The two had an argument and the complainant moved out of the home. For several months, the two communicated via email, WhatsApp and met. There continued to be arguments but there was a decision to reconcile until A.M. had accused the complainant of only wanting his money and had asked for her to repay him a significant amount of money. Further, the complainant was angry that A.M. and his cousin were allegedly sharing pictures that she wanted to be kept private (in actuality, there was nothing to this allegation). The complainant went to police in August of 2019. A.M. went to the police and A.M. was charged with the criminal offences. A.M. retained Joseph Neuberger of Neuberger & Partners LLP, Toronto Criminal Lawyers, to defend him on the charges. After Joseph Neuberger obtained all of the disclosure, he had A.M.’s cell phone sent to a tech expert to extract deleted messaging between A.M. and the complainant. Over 1000 messages was extracted including videos, pictures and a host of images post-dating the end of the relationship, and prior to the end of the relationship. A vast amount of the material was highly relevant to refuting the complainant’s narrative and specific facts of each of the charges. The charges ranged in dates covering 2018 up to December 26th, 2018. The complainant had asserted in her statement to police that after she left the home of A.M., she wanted nothing to do with A.M. and never saw him again in person and rarely communicated with him. The vast number of messages, images and videos, undermined her evidence. Joseph Neuberger obtained the meta data to confirm the dates of all messages and images. The defence brough a section 276/278 Application prior to trial to admit “other sexual activity” evidence and messages as relevant evidence to rebut the narrative of the complainant and her characterization of the relationship both before December 26th and after. The Application was successful, and all material was ruled admissible. The matter went to trial and Joseph Neuberger cross-examined the complainant for two and half days prior to asking for an adjournment to then bring a mid-trial application to admit other “other sexual history” evidence and further messages. In cross-examination the complainant, when answering, denied a number of obvious facts that were set out in the messages and asserted that she never attended A.M.’s home after December 26th among other facts that were inaccurate. The mid-trial Application was carefully drafted, argued and succeeded in full. After the ruling on the mid-trial Application, the complainant refused to attend for further cross-examination by Joseph Neuberger, and the Crown conceded a directed verdict of not guilty on all charges of sexual assault and assault.
Client found not guilty of a 9 count Information of Sexual Assault x 2, Sexual Interference x 2, Assault choking x 2 and Assault x 3 after a five-day trial in the Ontario Court of Justice, Brampton. V.S. was in a deteriorating marriage. There were two children, a daughter, and a son. V.S. was travelling a fair amount each month and hence was away from the home missing time with the children. In the fall of 2020, the complainant, the ex-wife, had an argument with V.S. about his travels and said he should limit his time with the children as it is too hard on them when he travels. The couple had other arguments, but the marriage was failing and V.S. asked for a divorce and she had found a file the contained correspondence with a family lawyer. Over the next couple of months, the children started to be more distant, and his daughter was becoming more and more defiant with his directions at home. In January of 2021, an argument ensued between V.S. and his daughter about her use of her cell phone and being on social media during school hours. V.S. went to grab the phone and the argument escalated. V.S. went out for a pre-scheduled business meeting and when he returned, he was arrested and charged with sexual assault allegations as against his daughter, and the assault charges as against his daughter, his then 5-year-old son and his wife. The one count against his wife alleged several different sets of allegations of domestic abuse. Joseph Neuberger and Diana Davison of Neuberger & Partners LLP, Toronto Criminal Defence Lawyers, were retained to defend him on the allegations. Joseph referred V.S. to a family lawyer and had him commence a divorce application and to seek some access to his children. Joseph worked closely with the family lawyer, and sure enough the Reply in the family law case from the complainant wife detailed all of the criminal allegations and added additional sexual allegations involving the daughter and son. The complainant wife was seeking unequal distribution of assets, sole possession of the house, sole custody of the children and $100,000 in damages for domestic abuse. The family court documents provided Joseph Neuberger with a rich source of information to cross-examine the former wife and to allege parental alienation. In fact, given the statements of the children, it was a very clear case of parental alienation. A 278 Application was brought to tender various documents, messages and pictures that illustrated over seven years a very close bonded relationship with both children. Joseph and Diana spent considerable time with the client helping him get ready for trial. He was emotional and worried about the trial. In addition, a detailed cross-examination was drafted. At trial, Joseph was able to establish through cross-examination material inconsistencies in the evidence of each witness, that the younger son was confused and heavily influenced by his sister and mother during the fall of 2020 and including just before going to the police being told about memories he forgot. Even before trial, it came out in cross-examination that while the wife, and the two children were driving to court, the complainant wife told the young son to remember details that were NOT in his statement to police. Under cross-examination, the complainant wife denied saying anything to the son or daughter. In cross-examination of the daughter, it came out not only that her sexual assault allegations were inconsistent and not plausible, but that during the fall of 2020 the complainant wife, her mother, had co-opted the daughter to help her get sole custody of her and her brother. There was a vast amount of evidence developed through cross-examination to demonstrate collusion and tainting of evidence. V.S. testified and denied the allegations. After the evidence, Joseph Neuberger drafted detailed closing written submissions and the Court ultimately found V.S. not guilty of all charges.
M.F. was charged with Assault, Assault with Weapon, and Breach of Recognizance/Peace Bond out of 1000 Finch courthouse, Toronto. M.F. was bound by a s. 810 peace bond at the time of her conflict with her husband. It was alleged that M.F. became jealous over her husband’s text messages she saw on his phone and started to hit him. Furthermore, it was alleged that she took her laptop and started hitting her husband with her laptop. The husband called police and M.F. was arrested. M.F retained Mariya Protsenko from Neuberger and Partners LLP, Toronto Criminal Lawyers. The aggravating factor was the fact that M.F. was previously charged with a Domestic Assault on her ex-husband and she entered into a s.810 peace. Mariya put together a large volume of information on the client – background, employment, status in Canada, text messages with the husband, photos provided by the client, as well as the client’s version of events that would ultimately have been her Defence at trial. Mariya had a number of discussions with the Crown Attorney and encouraged the Crown Attorney to wait until M.F. completed counseling and the counseling report is produced. At the end, the therapy report was excellent, and the Crown recognized deficiencies with the complainant husband’s evidence on the assault allegations. The Crown Attorney agreed to have M.F. enter a common law peace bond and the charges against her were withdrawn.
Charge of Assault withdrawn prior to trial, Newmarket. S.J. was charged with Assault arising from S.J.’s daughter having an altercation with a classmate. Later on, the mother of the classmate came to the house of S.J. to talk about the altercation. The two had an argument and S.J. ended up striking the classmate on her face. Then S.J. and the mother of the classmate started to fight with each other. Afterward, the mother of the classmate called police. Police arrived, spoke to the classmate and her mother after which S.J was charged with one count of Assault. S.J. retained Mariya Protsenko and Daisy Zhang of Neuberger and Partners, Criminal Lawyers Toronto, to represent her. Mariya spoke to S.J. in length and received the background story for the altercation between S.J.’s daughter and the classmate. Mariya had a pre-trial with the prosecutor where she presented S.J.’s side of the story with some corroborating information gathered during the defence investigation. An agreement was made for S.J. to complete conflict management therapy and upon completion the charge was formally withdrawn.
Charges of Assault, Assault with a Weapon and Forcible Confinement withdrawn prior to setting a trial date, Toronto. B.O. was having a break-up argument with his live-in girlfriend. Tempers got heated and B.O. asked for the complainant to leave. The complainant went down to the concierge and complained of being assaulted. Police were called and B.O. was charged. Joseph Neuberger, Neuberger & Partners LLP, Toronto Criminal Lawyers, was retained to defend the charges. Once the disclosure was obtained, Joseph Neuberger compared the complainant’s statement with video footage provided by the client. Clearly the video footage provided by the client did not show any physical altercation, but what was interesting was the complainant’s description of the alleged assaults that was wildly different that even the unfolding of the argument that was captured on the video footage. The condo had internal footage in the main hallway and common areas in the home, but not the bedroom. Nevertheless, the complainant had described being pinned up against the front door of the condo while being yelled at to leave. Defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger provided the video footage to the assigned Crown along with the transcribed statement of the complainant. As a result, all charges were withdrawn. * Unfortunately, not all accused persons have internal surveillance in the main and common areas of their home. Fortunately, this client did.
Charges of Sexual Assault x 2 withdrawn after successful Application brought under section 276/278 of the Criminal Code for the admission of prior sexual history evidence and documents, Newmarket. P.M. was charged several years after the end of his relationship with the complainant. The two dated in high school for about a year and a half. The two broke up and remained friends. Over the course of the time, the complainant started to suggest in messages and over calls that he had forced her into sex on a number of occasions that was not consensual. P.M. remained friends with the complainant but tried to distance himself. After a number of communications over the course of weeks, the complainant stopped communication and then went to the police and P.M. was charged with two counts of historical sexual assault. Joseph Neuberger, Neuberger & Partners LLP, was retained to defend the charges. Joseph Neuberger had Diana Davison assist on the defence, and there was considerable time devoted to investigating the past history o f P.M. and the complainant including gathering all past communications that totalled over 1000 messages, and several letters. The documentation was extremely helpful in understanding the background to the relationship but more importantly the activities between P.M. and the complainant was unusually detailed in the messages. In particular, one letter sent by the complainant just prior to the end of the relationship was highly relevant as to the true nature of their intimacy and significantly rebutted the narrative of the complainant. Joseph Neuberger prepared for trial and brought a motion to introduce prior sexual history evidence, and a series of relevant communications including this one letter. The Application, Factum and Affidavit of the client was drafted and filed. The Application was argued over the course of two days and was successful. The Application and Factum was drafted laying out in great detail the evidence that undermined the complainant’s version of events as well as the defence evidence. The drafting of these applications is very important to laying out a foundation for the admission of prior sexual history and communications between the parties. Once the Application was granted, the Crown spoke with Joseph Neuberger, and a determination was made that there was no reasonable prospect of conviction. As a result, the two charges of sex assault were withdrawn.
B.G. was charged with Voyeurism, Distribution of an Intimate image and Assault, Newmarket. BG discovered through social media that her boyfriend of 3 years was living with and engaged to another woman. RG and the fiancé discussed the relationship over Facebook messenger. In responding to the fiancé’s questions, RG sent photos to prove the relationship. In retaliation the boyfriend sent photos of RG to her family members and then made a complaint to police providing a different version of events. Grace Condello of Neuberger & Partners LLP, Toronto Criminal Lawyers, was retained to defend BG. Grace Condello conducted extensive research regarding the case law and the facts in the case including extensive messaging between B.G. and the complainant. Grace prepared a package to the Crown Attorney’s office to establish that it was not in the public interest to prosecutor B.G. Thus, the charges of Voyeurism, Distribution of an Intimate Image and Assault were withdrawn.
Charge of Domestic Assault withdrawn after extensive pre-trials, Brampton. The client and his wife were having a serious argument. The complainant left the house and went to her brother’s house. Later that evening she called police and R.A was charged. Joseph Neuberger and Grace Condello were retained to defend R.A. R.A. immediately gave Joseph and Grace a screenshot of a text sent the day after he was charged stating “I am really sorry I lied to police that you hurt me. My brother made me call police and lie about you.” That message was turned over to the officer in charge and the Crown with a letter asking for an investigation into a false statement and possibly a charge of public mischief. Nothing was done about the text. When disclosure was received the statement was extremely brief and so vague it undermined the allegation. Just an assertion that R.A. punched the complainant as he was upset about something about the house. No details or real context. No injuries. After having a series of pre-trials, the Crown agreed that there was no basis to move forward with the criminal case. The charge of Assault was withdrawn.
Past results are not necessarily indicative of future results and that the amount recovered and other litigation outcomes will vary according to the facts in individual cases.