The criminal justice system can be daunting, but you don’t need to go through it alone. Our Criminal lawyers are here to guide you every step of the way.
Contact Our Firm

M.F. was charged with Domestic Assault, and Mischief cause damage to property. M.F. was involved in a verbal argument with the complainant that escalated to police being called. The complainant called the police a second time and advised police that M.F. caused damage to his property and assaulted him. MF retained Joseph Neuberger and Grace Condello who bought an Application under section 502(2) of the Criminal Code of Canada to vary her release order as she was nine months pregnant and under extreme stress. The date was scheduled and disclosure was quickly obtained. Two pre-trials occurred. The Crown conceded the Application had merit and agreed that the charges should be withdrawn. All charges were withdrawn prior to the first court date and prior to the complainant having to attend for pictures and prints.
Charges of Assault, Forcible Confinement, and Utter Threats withdrawn prior to setting trial dates.
P.A. was involved in a verbal argument with her boyfriend that escalated to a physical confrontation. Despite PA locking herself in her room, the complainant called police and P.A. was charged. P.A. retained Grace Condello of Neuberger & Partners LLP, Criminal Lawyers Toronto, to defend the charges. The disclosure clearly noted that P.A. sought safety in the bathroom after an argument initiated by her boyfriend. Grace Condello booked an in-person pre-trial with the assigned Crown well prior to the first court appearance. During the pre-trial background information was provided, along with character letters. There was discussion about the disclosure and that the boyfriend not only initiated the argument by name-calling P.A. but was physically imposing and threatening. Ms. Condello and the Crown agreed that it was not in the public interest to prosecute. The charges were withdrawn prior to the first court date.

Charge of Domestic Assault withdrawn in the Ontario Court of Justice, Barrie prior to setting trial dates. R.B. and his wife were in an argument over a minor matter. However, it escalated and the complainant called police alleging a significant assault with multiple punches. Joseph Neuberger and Grace Condello were retained to defence the case. The disclosure did not establish evidence consistent with the alleged seriousness and force of the assault. At a pre-trial, discussions surrounded the couple’s unhealthy coping techniques to martial disagreements. R.B. voluntarily attended 21 sessions of therapy directed at conflict management in an intimate partner relationship. The complainant took remedial steps as well. She in fact retained a criminal lawyer of her own to communicate her own conduct and desire to have the charge withdrawn. Ultimately, meaningful steps were taken by all concerned to address the dynamic and the Crown withdrew the domestic assault charge.

Charges of Mischief Under and Utter Death Threats withdrawn without setting trial dates. N.V. got into a road rage argument with another party and during the course of the altercation, may have made some unfortunate comments and broke a window. N.V. was coming to the aid of an elderly woman who the complainant had an inappropriate exchange with. Joseph Neuberger and Grace Condello of Neuberger & Partners LLP, were retained to defend N.V. A plan was implemented for conflict management therapy, restitution and evidence of community service. The assigned Crown was very pleasant and agreed it was not in the public interest to prosecute. Thus, after a successful course of therapy, community service and restitution, the charges of Utter Threat and Mischief to Property were withdrawn and the client signed a common law peace bond.

Client acquitted of assault causing bodily harm and sex assault following a two-day trial at the Ontario Court of Justice, St. Catharines. The complainant alleged non-consensual cutting during a BDSM show-and-tell. The accused testified that the cutting was consensual. Mr. Whitfield argued successfully at a pretrial motion for the admission of text messages sent unsolicited from the Complainant to the accused praising the time she spent with him and requesting further BDSM activities. Defence submissions focused on significant inconsistencies in the Complainant’s evidence and on the accused’s believable and largely unchallenged testimony. The judge believed the accused’s version of events and acquitted him on the spot.

Appeal granted at the London Superior Court of Justice for Ontario. The appellant was convicted of one count of uttering threats and two counts of domestic assault against the Complainant, his ex-wife, despite significant inconsistencies in her evidence. Those inconsistencies concerned the frequency and nature of the alleged abuse; the trial judge dismissed them as the expected result of filtering mechanisms inherent in criminal legal proceedings. Mr. Whitfield argued successfully on appeal that such a manner of resolution was unknown to law, unsupported by the trial record, and contrary to the integrity of the legal profession and the police. The appellate judge granted the appeal and a new trial has been ordered.

Charges of Sexual Assault and Forcible Confinement withdrawn prior to setting trial dates, Toronto. F.C. was in a casual relationship with the complainant for over a year. One night while at the Royal York Hotel, the two became embroiled in an argument after having spent the night together. F.C. did not want to assist the complainant with a business endeavour and the two parted unfavourably. A week later, F.C. was contacted by police and it was alleged that he did not stop sexual intercourse when the complainant had asked. The complainant alleged some BDSM sexual play that she did not consent to. As such, F.C. was charged with Sex Assault and Forcible Confinement. Joseph Neuberger of Neuberger & Partners LLP was retained. Joseph Neuberger obtained copies of an extensive record of messages between the complainant and F.C. that provided a very detailed outline of the relationship including communications after the night of the alleged sexual assault. It became clear from the messages that the complainant was upset about the rebuke about financial assistance. Further defence investigative steps were taken and the complainant continued to email F.C. with many of the messages giving concerns as to her mental health, reliability, and motive to fabricate. After reviewing the disclosure and the statement of the complainant, Joseph Neuberger prepared a memo to the Crown setting out source material and a breakdown of the case as to why there was no reasonable prospect of conviction. After multiple pre-trials and a judicial pre-trial, it was agreed that F.C. would sign a common law peace bond and the charges would be withdrawn.

Charges of domestic assault, forcible confinement and mischief withdrawn prior to setting a trial date, Orangeville. R.C. and his wife were horsing around, and a raw comment was made that resulted in an allegation of assault and other criminal allegations. Police were called and R.C. was arrested. Joseph Neuberger and Grace Condello of Neuberger & Partners LLP were retained to defend the charges. After receiving the disclosure, the statement of the complainant – R.C.’s wife – was incredibly inconsistent alleging that he struck her after she told him he was drunk to her striking him after he said she was being …. The complainant alleged R.C. grabbed her and tried to take her phone. However, police dash cam video of the complainant disclosed no such allegations and that she was just angry and wanted him removed from the house. After very productive discussions with the Crown, Grace Condello and Joseph Neuberger worked out with the Crown that the parties could benefit from therapy and then a withdrawal once successfully completed. The Crown took a very thoughtful and pragmatic approach. Ultimately, the charges were withdrawn.

Charges of Sexual Assault x 2 and Sexual Exploitation withdrawn, Superior Court, Owen Sound. W.M. met a younger lady through an ad posted for a travel companion. The two met, seemed to connect, and agreed to travel together. W.M. took her shopping and they picked some places to visit in Ontario. They both packed and travelled. At their destination in Owen Sound, the lady passed a note to the hotel reception clerk that she needed help. She wrote in the note that she was kidnapped and suggested she was sex trafficked. Police attended and W.M. was arrested. Joseph Neuberger was retained to defend the case. Diana Davison, a men’s rights advocate with the firm was assigned to the file. In addition, a private investigator was retained by Joseph Neuberger to secure and possibly obtain all CCTV footage of all places and hotels visited by W.M. and the complainant. The private investigator was successful to secure most video footage and most was provided to Joseph Neuberger. After disclosure was received and reviewed, Joseph Neuberger sought an order to return the cell phone and dash cam seized by police for a defence digital extraction. All retrieved messages, and video obtained and disclosed by the Crown completely discredited every aspect of the complainant’s statements. In addition, there appeared to be a mental health issue outlined by the complainant in one of her statements. Further disclosure requests were made about the mental health issues. Joseph Neuberger and Diana Davison prepared a detailed chart and memo for the Crown breaking down the statements and contradicting every aspect with messages and video evidence. Extensive pre-trials between the Crown and Joseph Neuberger were extremely productive. Joseph Neuberger provided the memo and chart to the Crown and all digital evidence was shared. The Crown rightly concluded that there was no reasonable prospect of conviction as the complainant fabricated the allegations. The charges of sex assault and sexual exploitation were withdrawn.

M.F. found not guilty following a trial on charges of Sexual Assault, Sexual Interference, and Invitation to Sexual Touching in the Ontario Court of Justice, Brampton. M.F.’s daughter, the complainant, alleged that during a seven-year period her father sexually assaulted her at least 10 times per month in the family residence despite the presence of several other family members living regularly at the residence during the entire time. M.F., as a result, was charged with multiple sexual offences after the complainant disclosed the alleged incidents to a friend at school. Their conversation was overheard by a teacher and immediately reported to the police. Reliability and credibility were the central issues at trial. Mid-way during the trial, the complainant’s evidence became problematic as she admitted that she had made everything up and lied to the police about her father. Initially, the Crown was intent on proceeding and intended to rely on her original statement to the police after having the complainant declared a hostile witness. The matter was adjourned briefly to allow discussions between counsel. Michael Bury spent considerable time negotiating with the Crown and highlighting the obvious problems the Crown now had with the Complainant’s contradictory evidence. Applying the relevant legal principles, the trial judge found M.F. Not Guilty after the Crown invited the judge to dismiss the charges.
Past results are not necessarily indicative of future results and that the amount recovered and other litigation outcomes will vary according to the facts in individual cases.